The Challenge of Addressing Hidden Chemical Food Risks

Need to Know
- Unlike microbial contamination, chemical contamination may not cause immediate illness, making it difficult to detect through traditional food safety surveillance
- Cases involving PFAS in beer, lead in cinnamon applesauce, and heavy metals in foods for young children highlight different contamination pathways and testing challenges
- Effective chemical testing plans should identify potential contamination sources, prioritize strategic sampling points, and establish response procedures before testing begins
When Salmonella or E. coli bacteria contaminate food, illnesses can alert health departments to a problem. Investigators may then trace those illnesses to a product, prompting a recall.
Chemical contamination in food may not give that kind of warning. A child who eats applesauce with elevated lead, or an adult who drinks beer containing per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), also known as "forever chemicals," may have no immediate symptoms. The potential health effects depend on the chemical, how much people consume, how often they consume it, and their susceptibility. Some effects may not become apparent until long after exposure. As these exposures can go unnoticed, they are easy to miss.
Food safety programs may be able to identify more of these problems if testing plans started with three questions:
- Where could a contaminant get into this product?
- Where in the supply chain is testing most likely to find it?
- What actions will be taken if the result comes back high?
Testing Is Selective by Design
Testing every batch or lot of food for every chemical would not be practical. Manufacturers use supplier qualification and sampling programs to check products and ingredients. Regulators decide where to inspect and sample based on risk, and they screen some imports. In the U.S., several agencies share oversight. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA's) Total Diet Study measures contaminants in foods prepared as people would eat them, helping estimate dietary exposure rather than assessing individual brands.
This selective approach reflects limited resources. Still, contaminants can enter the supply chain through soil, irrigation water, feed, spices, processing water, equipment, or packaging. For newer contaminants, validated test methods, occurrence data, and regulatory limits may not yet be available.
Three examples illustrate different challenges in detecting and preventing chemical contamination: PFAS in beer, lead in cinnamon applesauce, and arsenic and lead in foods for young children.
PFAS in Beer
Beer is mostly water, making a brewery's water supply a potential source of contamination. A study1 of U.S. retail beers found PFAS in most samples. Levels were higher in beers brewed where local water was known to be contaminated.
The findings point to brewing water as an important place to investigate. Testing only the finished beverage may reveal contamination without identifying its source. Testing brewing water alongside the product could help identify contamination in the water supply earlier and inform decisions about treatment or sourcing.
Looking for quick answers on food safety topics?
Try Ask FSM, our new smart AI search tool.
Ask FSM →
Lead in Cinnamon Applesauce
The 2023–2024 applesauce pouch investigation2 began when blood-lead screening found elevated levels in young children. County environmental health staff investigated potential sources and learned through interviews that the children had eaten the same applesauce product.
Testing confirmed lead in the pouches. The investigation led to public advisories and recalls, and agencies traced the contamination to cinnamon used as an ingredient.
Ingredient specifications and supplier checks are intended to help identify problems before products reach consumers. In this case, screening children for lead exposure brought the contamination to light first.
Arsenic and Lead in Foods for Young Children
Rice absorbs inorganic arsenic from soil and irrigation water more readily than many other grains. Young children's exposure depends on both the concentration in a food and how much they eat relative to their body weight.
FDA has set an action level for inorganic arsenic in infant rice cereal.3 Through its Closer to Zero initiative, it has also set action levels for lead in processed foods for babies and young children.
For these foods, ingredient sourcing, testing, and product formulation can help reduce contaminant levels before final product testing begins. Unlike the applesauce investigation, this example concerns an ongoing sourcing and exposure challenge rather than a single contamination event.
Implications for Surveillance
The three examples reinforce the key questions that should guide a chemical testing plan: where contamination could enter a product, where testing could detect it, and what actions should be taken if detected levels exceed relevant response thresholds.
Identifying likely entry points helps determine where to sample. For beer, that could mean testing brewing water alongside the finished beverage. For cinnamon applesauce, it could mean testing cinnamon before it enters production. For infant rice cereal, it could mean testing rice ingredients before they are used. The aim is to choose sampling points where a finding can guide a decision, rather than relying only on final product testing.
The testing method also needs to fit the question. A non-detect result does not establish that every chemical of concern is absent. It should be interpreted in light of which compounds the method measures and how low of a concentration it can detect. There is also power in utilizing newer technologies such as non-targeted chemical analysis to screen for unknowns or unintentionally added substances to a product. This type of analysis will help an organization determine a suspect list for future testing and monitoring in a product.
Before results arrive, companies should agree on what would trigger a response and who would be responsible. Depending on the finding, that could mean holding product, conducting additional testing, investigating a supplier, switching sources, or reformulating. Confirming an unexpected result and taking precautionary steps while it is investigated are separate decisions; a response plan should account for both.
Supply chain testing is only part of surveillance. The applesauce case shows how public health screening can uncover contamination that was not identified within the supply chain. Testing budgets will always be finite, but coordination among food companies, suppliers, regulators, researchers, and local health departments can help connect findings, investigate sources, and identify chemical risks sooner.
References
- RTI International. "PFAS and beer: RTI study reveals drinking water as primary source of contamination in brewing." April 30, 2025. https://www.rti.org/news/pfas-beer-water-contamination-study.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). "Investigation of Elevated Lead & Chromium Levels: Cinnamon Applesauce Pouches (November 2023)." Current as of October 3, 2024. https://www.fda.gov/food/outbreaks-foodborne-illness/investigation-elevated-lead-chromium-levels-cinnamon-applesauce-pouches-november-2023.
- FDA. Guidance for Industry: Action Levels for Lead in Processed Food Intended for Babies and Young Children. January 2025. https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/guidance-industry-action-levels-lead-processed-food-intended-babies-and-young-children.





