Food Safety
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Food Safety
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • White Papers
  • PRODUCTS
  • TOPICS
    • Contamination Control
    • Food Types
    • Management
    • Process Control
    • Regulatory
    • Sanitation
    • Supply Chain
    • Testing and Analysis
  • PODCAST
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Food Safety Five Newsreel
    • eBooks
    • FSM Distinguished Service Award
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
    • Videos
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • MORE
    • ENEWSLETTER >
      • Archive Issues
      • Subscribe to eNews
    • Store
    • Sponsor Insights
  • WEBINARS
  • FOOD SAFETY SUMMIT
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Editorial Advisory Board
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP!
RegulatoryFDAInspection

FDA’s Right to Take Photographs in Your Facility: Or Not

September 16, 2014

Most food manufacturing companies maintain strict written policies for plant visitors. Besides safety directives and personal protective equipment, visitors are routinely required to sign confidentiality agreements that protect trade secrets and confidential information that may be viewed by visitors while at the facility. Not only are confidentiality policies good business practice, but they are often contractual requirements with the customer. Private label customers outsource production with the understanding that formulas and processes will be protected.

Routinely, these confidentiality agreements also preclude the taking of any photographs or video during the visit. Photos and videos are the most likely method by which confidential information is inadvertently captured and taken off site. Information on film won’t be seen by the company or visitor before the visit ends and the company may never learn that confidential information was captured.

But what about representatives of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) who show up for either a routine inspection or an investigation? What rights do manufacturing companies have with respect to confidentiality of customer information, including the taking of photographs or videos by FDA? And what control do they have, if any, of the means by which photos are taken for evidence of alleged adulteration? FDA certainly believes it has the right to take photos as a part of its routine oversight responsibilities. But what position should a manufacturing company take when FDA is at the front door?

FDA’s Position
Each year the FDA issues an Investigations Operational Manual (IOM) (www.fda.gov/ICECI/Inspections/IOM/default.htm), which is the primary source of directives for its field investigators and inspectors. It contains the everyday policies and procedures for its representatives to follow when entering facilities over which the FDA has oversight responsibilities. With respect to photographs, the IOM recommends a rather aggressive approach:

5.3.4.1 - In-Plant Photographs
Do not request permission from management to take photographs during an inspection. Take your camera into the firm and use it as necessary just as you use other inspectional equipment.

If management objects to taking photographs, explain that photos are an integral part of an inspection and present an accurate picture of plant conditions. Advise management the U. S. Courts have held that photographs may lawfully be taken as part of an inspection.

If management continues to refuse, provide them with the following references:

1. “Dow Chemical v. United States,” 476 U.S. 227 (1986). This Supreme Court decision dealt with aerial photographs by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, but the Court’s language seems to address the right to take photographs by any regulatory agency. The decision reads in part, “**When Congress invests an agency with enforcement and investigatory authority, it is not necessary to identify explicitly each and every technique that may be used in the course of executing the statutory mission.***”

2. “United States of America v. Acri Wholesale Grocery Company, A Corporation, and JOSEPH D. ACRI and ANTHONY ACRI, Individuals,” U.S. District Court for Southern District of Iowa. 409 F. Supp. 529. Decided February 24, 1976.

If management refuses, obtain name and contact information for the firm’s legal counsel, and advise your district management immediately. If the firm does not have legal counsel on retainer, collect the name and contact information for the most responsible individual. District management will inform their ORA Regional Counselor in the Office of Chief Counsel (OCC) of the situation, and OCC will then contact the firm’s legal counsel or most responsible individual to discuss FDA’s legal right to take pictures during inspections. OCC will relay the results of this conversation to district management. If you have already taken some photos do not surrender film to management. Advise the firm it can obtain copies of the photos under the Freedom of Information Act.

FDA believes that there are statutory safeguards in place to protect the confidentiality of information and photographs that are collected in the course of its investigation per the provisions of several statutes [e.g., Trade Secrets Act (18 U.S.C. 1905), FD&C Act (21 U.S.C. 331(j)), the Freedom of Information Act, (5 U.S.C. 552) and the agency’s information disclosure regulations at 21 CFR Parts 20 and 21 govern the agency’s disclosure of information to the public. But it concedes that FDA personnel may disclose nonpublic information that is otherwise protected from disclosure to the public, if that disclosure is permitted by law and FDA’s procedures (see e.g. 21 U.S.C. 375(b)]. For example, FDA’s regulations, set forth in 21 CFR Parts 20 and 21, permit agency officials to disclose certain nonpublic information to other federal, state, local or foreign government officials, or to FDA’s contractors, when that disclosure is carried out according to law and FDA’s procedures.

Company’s Position
Given that FDA clearly intends to take photos whether in the scope of a routine inspection or a directed investigation, what, if anything, should the company’s response be? First it should be understood why a company may want to oppose FDA’s taking of photographs: a) it may violate the contracts with customers to allow photos to be taken without prior notice to the customer; b) the photos may ultimately include confidential or proprietary information that is totally irrelevant to the focus of FDA’s investigation; and c) singular, close-up photos of alleged small examples of adulteration can be prejudicial evidence in later litigation if taken out of context and exclude overall images of the plant’s Good Manufacturing Practices. For these reasons, a company may want to attempt to prohibit an FDA investigator from taking photos inside its plant.

The cases referenced by the IOM as authority for taking photos during investigations do not in fact totally stand for the conclusions FDA alleges. Both Dow Chemical and Acri Wholesale Grocery Company held that when a company had consented to an inspection, any photos taken during that inspection are admissible in later litigation. It is clear that FDA has a right to conduct investigations under its enforcement responsibilities [21 C.F.R. § 374(a)]. But if management takes the position before the inspection begins that no photographs are allowed, neither Dow Chemical nor Acri Wholesale Grocery Company apply. And according to the IOM, management’s refusal to allow photos should stop the inspection and the inspector should refer the conflict to the company’s legal counsel and the inspector’s district manager.
 
At some point, FDA will likely return with a warrant for the inspection. Because FDA’s standard warrant includes the specific authority to take photographs, the company’s legal counsel should be prepared to immediately file a motion to quash the warrant or seek an injunction challenging its scope. Restrictions on photography could be sought, which would preclude the photographing of confidential of proprietary information, unless necessary to document the alleged adulteration. If necessary, the proprietary information could by agreement be shielded or possibly redacted. Furthermore, if the goal is to be able to present an array of photos in later litigation that show the area of alleged adulteration in context to the overall plant, restrictions could be sought that photos be taken at periodic intervals throughout the plant. At a minimum, the company should simultaneously photograph or videotape the plant and overall area where the narrow photo of alleged adulteration is being photographed by FDA.

Conclusions
FDA has no statutory right to take photographs or video tapes during a routine inspection or an investigation. Agents have been given the directive to take photos without asking permission of the manufacturing company. Courts have held that photos are an acceptable part of a governmental agencies’ enforcement authority when the plant owner has consented to an inspection. What remains a viable option is to refuse any photography during the inspection and before the inspection begins, and seek legal restrictions on the photographic process beforehand.

Kathy Hardee, Esq., is co-chair of the Food & Agriculture Industry Group at Polsinelli, PC, which is comprised of a team of attorneys from every legal practice area and who each have a focused background in the food industry.

>
Author(s): Kathy Hardee, Esq.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • people holding baby chicks

    Serovar Differences Matter: Utility of Deep Serotyping in Broiler Production and Processing

    This article discusses the significance of Salmonella in...
    Methods
    By: Nikki Shariat Ph.D.
  • woman washing hands

    Building a Culture of Hygiene in the Food Processing Plant

    Everyone entering a food processing facility needs to...
    Training
    By: Richard F. Stier, M.S.
  • graphical representation of earth over dirt

    Climate Change and Emerging Risks to Food Safety: Building Climate Resilience

    This article examines the multifaceted threats to food...
    Management
    By: Maria Cristina Tirado Ph.D., D.V.M. and Shamini Albert Raj M.A.
Subscribe For Free!
  • eMagazine Subscription
  • Subscribe to eNewsletter
  • Manage My Preferences
  • Website Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Food Safety Magazine audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Food Safety Magazine or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • Deli Salads
    Sponsored byCorbion

    How Food Safety is Becoming the Ultimate Differentiator in Refrigerated and Prepared Foods

Popular Stories

Image of Tyson Foods logo and the logos of Tyson Foods brands

Tyson Foods is Reformulating Food Products to Eliminate Petroleum-Based Synthetic Dyes

USDA building.jpg

More Than 15,000 USDA Employees Take Trump Administration's Resignation Offer

Woman reading the warning label on a bottle of wine

A 40-Year Hangover: Efforts to Revive 1980s Advocacy About the Potential Negative Effects of Alcohol Consumption

Events

May 12, 2025

The Food Safety Summit

Stay informed on the latest food safety trends, innovations, emerging challenges, and expert analysis. Leave the Summit with actionable insights ready to drive measurable improvements in your organization. Do not miss this opportunity to learn from experts about contamination control, food safety culture, regulations, sanitation, supply chain traceability, and so much more.

May 14, 2025

Leveraging AI for a Safer Today and Tomorrow

Live Streaming from the Food Safety Summit: This session will highlight some of the early and visible benefits of using AI for data-informed decision making.

May 14, 2025

Recall Modernization Initiatives with the Consumer in Mind

Live Streaming from the Food Safety Summit: In this session, attendees will hear what industry and others have been doing to move this modernization forward faster for consumer safety.

View All

Products

Global Food Safety Microbial Interventions and Molecular Advancements

Global Food Safety Microbial Interventions and Molecular Advancements

See More Products
Environmental Monitoring Excellence eBook

Related Articles

  • Retrofit with Purpose: Take Your Food Facility to the Next Level

    See More
  • It’s Time to Take Stock of Your Food Company’s FDA Registration

    See More
  • Choosing the Right Pest Control Provider for Your Facility

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • 1119237963.jpg

    Food Safety in China: Science, Technology, Management and Regulation

  • 9781138070912.jpg

    Trends in Food Safety and Protection

  • 1119258073.jpg

    FSMA and Food Safety Systems: Understanding and Implementing the Rules

See More Products

Related Directories

  • Sciex

    SCIEX food testing solutions help you meet maximum residue limits with high-quality data that is right every time. The success and growth of your food testing lab depends on versatile mass spectrometry and capillary electrophoresis solutions that can manage whatever comes your way. Whether you are a commercial lab or a food manufacturer, the quality of the food testing data you acquire is vital to your business.
  • Heute Inc.

    ProfilGate® Clean Walking and Driving Zones- Clean and/or Sterilize Material Handling Equipment Wheels, Tires, Castors and also shoes with patented Brush and Grate system. Trap the dirt in the tray below and sterilize with the "Aqua" version. You cant keep dirt, dust, debris, and germs from entering your facility, you have to control it!!
×

Never miss the latest news and trends driving the food safety industry

eNewsletter | Website | eMagazine

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing