Study Compares Pathogen Risks in Farmed, Wild-Caught Food Animals Sold in Traditional Markets

A systematic review and meta-analysis comparing farmed and wild-caught wildlife sold in traditional food markets found that zoonotic pathogen presence varied by pathogen, host species, and production conditions. Although farmed animals generally had lower odds of parasitic infections, findings for bacterial pathogens were inconsistent, and evidence regarding viral pathogens was scarce.
Of the 20 studies included in the analysis, 17 involved aquatic species, including fish, shellfish, frogs, and freshwater turtles. Only three examined terrestrial species: rats, snakes, and water monitor lizards. No avian species and no mammals other than rats were represented.
Farmed Wildlife Had Lower Odds of Some Parasitic Zoonoses
Across 10 studies assessing parasitic zoonoses in aquatic species, farmed animals had lower odds of infection than wild-caught animals. Among fish specifically, farmed animals had lower odds of zoonotic parasites.
The researchers suggested that managed production environments could reduce exposure to intermediate hosts involved in the complex life cycles of parasites.
Bacterial Findings Were Mixed
Across aquatic species, there was no significant overall difference in bacterial zoonotic pathogen detection between farmed and wild-caught animals.
Interestingly, individual studies found higher odds of bacterial zoonoses among farmed frogs and freshwater turtles, both of which were tested for Salmonella. No statistically significant differences were observed for farmed versus wild-caught fish or shellfish.
Limited Viral Data
Only one included study compared viral pathogen detection, reporting lower odds of coronavirus detection among farmed rats than wild-caught rats.
Researchers Suggest Importance of Environmental, Management Conditions
While the authors cautioned against generalizing the findings due to study limitations, they concluded that environmental and management conditions, rather than whether wildlife is farmed or wild-caught alone, likely influence zoonotic hazard. The researchers called for standardized comparative research across additional species and pathogens.
Looking for quick answers on food safety topics?
Try Ask FSM, our new smart AI search tool.
Ask FSM →









