Food Safety
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Food Safety
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • White Papers
  • PRODUCTS
  • TOPICS
    • Contamination Control
    • Food Types
    • Management
    • Process Control
    • Regulatory
    • Sanitation
    • Supply Chain
    • Testing and Analysis
  • PODCAST
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Food Safety Five Newsreel
    • eBooks
    • FSM Distinguished Service Award
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
    • Videos
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • MORE
    • ENEWSLETTER >
      • Archive Issues
      • Subscribe to eNews
    • Store
    • Sponsor Insights
  • WEBINARS
  • FOOD SAFETY SUMMIT
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Editorial Advisory Board
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP!
ManagementRecall/Crisis Management

Fear of the Unknown Cause of Contamination

July 6, 2017

It is the worst nightmare for many in the food industry—a massive recall due to contamination or spoilage. While companies can mitigate supply chain risk by insuring against damage or contamination, what happens when the actual cause of damage is unknown?

Commercial general liability policies typically provide coverage to insureds for losses resulting from property damage caused by an “occurrence.” An “occurrence” is usually defined in the policy as “an accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same harmful conditions.” Thus, these policies are meant to insure the policyholder’s negligent acts rather than intentional ones. In the context of food recalls, however, the exact cause of the food damage, whether contamination, spoilage or something else, may be unknown. In those circumstances, insurers often argue that the resulting damage is not covered because it is not clear that it was caused by an accident—and thus an “occurrence” under the policy to trigger coverage. Recent cases from around the country support claims for coverage even where the cause of loss is unknown.

For example, in The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. v. Raw Seafoods, Inc., 91 Mass. App. Ct. 401 (2017), a Massachusetts appellate court held that the insured seafood processing facility was covered for nearly $600,000 in damages plus interest that it was ordered to pay as a result of a shipment of spoiled scallops for which the cause of spoilage was unknown. According to the facility’s policy, the insurer was legally obligated to pay for damages resulting from unintentional or accidental property damage. Yet, the insurer denied coverage for the loss of the scallops, arguing that the insured could not prove that the loss resulted from an accident.

The court rejected the insurer’s argument and found that though the precise cause of damage to the scallops was unknown, the damage to the scallops constituted an accident, and thus a covered occurrence under the policy. Because a similar incident had never occurred before or since, the court determined that the harm was unintentional.

In The Travelers Property Casualty Co. of America v. USA Container Co., Inc., No. 14-3685 (3d. Cir. April 18, 2017), the insured’s claim arose out of corn syrup that was damaged during the insured’s transport. A corn syrup distributor sued the insured transporter after it was forced to sell the damaged syrup at a reduced rate. To compensate for its loss, the insured filed a claim with its insurer.

The insurer denied coverage, arguing that the damage to the corn syrup could not constitute a covered “occurrence” under the policy because it was the result of what the insurer deemed “faulty workmanship.” Like in the Raw Seafoods case, however, the court found that the damage to the corn syrup was considered an occurrence because it was the result of an unintentional harm caused by the insured’s negligent conduct. Moreover, the court held that the faulty workmanship and precautionary recalls exceptions did not limit the insured’s coverage because the damaged corn syrup did not have to be recalled, replaced or repaired.

Similarly, the court in Cheer Pack North America, LLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company and Continental Casualty Co., Case No. 15-14135-FDS (D. Mass. April 28, 2017), held in favor of the insured, rejecting the insurer’s argument that it had no duty to defend its insureds in a lawsuit, in part, because it alleged the property damage at issue was not due to a covered “occurrence.” The insured, which manufactured flexible pouches with screw caps for various food products such as baby food, sought coverage for a suit brought by a provider of organic foods and the manufacturer for those snacks following a voluntary recall. The suit alleged that Cheer Pack failed to handle the products in a clean and sanitary environment, causing bacterial growth. Cheer Pack’s insurer denied coverage, arguing that the claim for property damage was not caused by an occurrence. The court, however, disagreed and held in favor of Cheer Pack, because it determined that the failure of the pouches to maintain a hermetic seal during processing was an unexpected incident and thus an “occurrence” that caused the contamination and damages.

Although food industry risk managers work to mitigate the risks of contamination or spoilage through food safety control processes, they can only do so much to combat the unknown causes of damage. Fortunately, insurance can help cover resulting losses and claims, including the costs of recall, when damage results from “the unknown.” Nonetheless, as the cases above demonstrate, many insurance claims can result in litigation. To avoid a lengthy coverage dispute with insurers and to ensure maximum coverage for their losses, insureds in the food industry should carefully consider the specific provisions in their policies and the relevant case law and also consult knowledgeable counsel as soon as they become aware of a potential claim.

Syed S. Ahmad, Esq., is a partner in Hunton & Williams LLP’s insurance coverage practice in the Washington, D.C. office. Andrea DeField, Esq., is an associate in the firm’s insurance coverage practice in the Miami office.


Author(s): Syed S. Ahmad, Esq., and Andrea DeField, Esq.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • people holding baby chicks

    Serovar Differences Matter: Utility of Deep Serotyping in Broiler Production and Processing

    This article discusses the significance of Salmonella in...
    Contamination Control
    By: Nikki Shariat Ph.D.
  • woman washing hands

    Building a Culture of Hygiene in the Food Processing Plant

    Everyone entering a food processing facility needs to...
    Food Prep/Handling
    By: Richard F. Stier, M.S.
  • graphical representation of earth over dirt

    Climate Change and Emerging Risks to Food Safety: Building Climate Resilience

    This article examines the multifaceted threats to food...
    Best Practices
    By: Maria Cristina Tirado Ph.D., D.V.M. and Shamini Albert Raj M.A.
Manage My Account
  • eMagazine Subscription
  • Subscribe to eNewsletter
  • Manage My Preferences
  • Website Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Food Safety Magazine audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Food Safety Magazine or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • mold
    Sponsored byIFC

    Tackling Mold Remediation in Food Processing Plants

  • a worker in a food processing plant
    Sponsored byLPS® DETEX®

    How a Beverage Facility Improved Food Safety and Compliance with Detectable Packaging Solutions

  • Two men standing in a produce storage facility having a discussion.
    Sponsored byOrkin Commercial

    Staying Compliant With FSMA

Popular Stories

sunflower oil

Louisiana Passes ‘MAHA’ Bill Targeting More Than 40 Ingredients, Including Seed Oils, Dyes, Sweeteners

smoked salmon in oil

Study Shows Food Type Significantly Affects Listeria’s Ability to Survive Digestion, Cause Sickness

FSM podcast

Ep. 197. Jatin Patel: Lessons Learned and Best Practices for Handling a Recall

Events

July 15, 2025

Hygienic Design Risk Management: Industry Challenges and Global Insights

Live: July 15, 2025 at 11:00 am EDT: From this webinar, attendees will learn the importance of hygienic design to ensure food safety and sanitation effectiveness.

July 22, 2025

Beyond the Binder: Digital Management of Food Safety

Live: July 22, 2025 at 3:00 pm EDT: During this webinar, attendees will learn best practices for the use of digital food safety management systems across industry and regulatory agencies.

August 7, 2025

Achieve Active Managerial Control of Major Risk Factors Using a Food Safety Management System

Live: August 7, 2025 at 2:00 pm EDT: From this webinar, attendees will learn about changes to the FDA Food Code, which now includes a requirement for FSMS. 

View All

Products

Global Food Safety Microbial Interventions and Molecular Advancements

Global Food Safety Microbial Interventions and Molecular Advancements

See More Products
Environmental Monitoring Excellence eBook

Related Articles

  • person cutting raw chicken in home kitchen

    A Quarter of Cooks Cause Cross-Contamination Whether They Wash Chicken or Not

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • 9781498721776.jpg

    Handbook of Food Processing: Food Safety, Quality, and Manufacturing Processes

  • 1444333348.jpg

    Handbook of Food Safety Engineering

  • 1119053595.jpg

    Food Safety for the 21st Century: Managing HACCP and Food Safety throughout the Global Supply Chain, 2E

See More Products

Events

View AllSubmit An Event
  • October 24, 2024

    The Future of Metal and X-Ray Detection in Plastics

    On Demand: From this webinar, attendees will learn how to enhance safety and compliance in their F&B operations.
View AllSubmit An Event

Related Directories

  • ETQ, part of Hexagon

    ETQ Reliance is the world’s most flexible, powerful & easy-to-use advanced Quality Management System. Automate & standardize all aspects of quality, from document control, training, CAPA, audits, supply chain & more. Benefit from improved compliance, enhanced reputation, reduced costs, speed to market & visibility into your supply chain.
  • Saldesia "Goddess of Food Safety"

    Saldesia is a distributor of Food Safety products and solutions. We are focused on supplying the Quality, Production, Safety and Sanitation departments. Product lines include Color Coded, Metal Detectable, Antimicrobial Flooring & Mats, Workwear, Footwear, Spray Nozzles, and more!
×

Never miss the latest news and trends driving the food safety industry

eNewsletter | Website | eMagazine

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing